patching...
Welcome back, Patch Blogger!

Embattled Police Captain Reaches Retirement Agreement with Borough

Fair Lawn police Capt. Joseph Cook, the target of multiple lawsuits and a 2012 internal affairs investigation, has retired, effective Thursday.

 

Fair Lawn police Capt. Joseph Cook, who faced administrative charges stemming from an internal affairs investigation last year, retired Thursday rather than fight the matter before the Office of Administrative Law in Newark, his attorney Patrick Toscano said.

The borough placed Cook on paid administrative leave last June and brought administrative charges against him in early July. At the time, Toscano said Cook was given two options upon his return to the department: accept a demotion to Lieutenant or take a suspension.

Cook, who maintains his innocence, returned to his previous job within the department following the investigation. He initially sought a court hearing rather than agree to either of the borough's options, but after months of negotiations, instead worked out a retirement agreement with the borough.

"There was no need to go to the OAL to try the administrative matter, as all matters concerning my client were settled to Captain Cook and the governing body's complete satisfaction," Toscano wrote in an email to Patch.

While the terms of the settlement are confidential, Toscano said he was "exceedingly and entirely satisfied" by the outcome.

Borough manager Tom Metzler and Mayor John Cosgrove confirmed Cook's departure, but declined comment on its terms.

“I wish Officer Cook well and I’m looking forward to the department moving forward," said Cosgrove, who campaigned on improving police department morale when he ran for council in 2011.

Metzler spoke highly of Cook's police work and wished him well in his retirement. He recalled being with Cook the day the future captain learned he'd been offered a job as a patrolman in 1986.

"I was with him the day he got his letter from the police department offering him a job...and I took the resignation letter from him," said Metzler, who was best friends with Cook's father. "I was there the first day and the last day of his career."

Cook earned an annual salary of $153,382 in 2012.

--

Follow Fair Lawn-Saddle Brook Patch on Facebook and Twitter, and subscribe to receive our daily newsletter in your inbox each morning

Related Topics: fair lawn patch, fair lawn police, fair lawn police captain, fair lawn settlement, joseph cook, and patrick toscano

tony F

1:43 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

don't put the idiot with 38 years in that spot....

Reply

Concerned

1:43 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

I hope the department can move forward. With him and Rose, the morale is HORRIBLE!!!

Reply

Dorothy Kilgallen

7:46 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

Lets see how many lawsuits commence once the council forces the Chief out. Get your wallets ready.

Reply

Madison

7:46 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

The full settlement will be published soon. Let's hope Cook was reasonable and not a crook. Fair Lawn taxpayers screwed again! When will it end?

Reply

LENNY

10:00 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

full year of pay while you are not working great deal. sure makes you feel good when you write that check each quarter to BORO FAIR LAWN !

Reply

LENNY

10:00 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

the story on line yesterday from the NORTH JERSEY NEWS said it was a full year on paid leave,

Reply
Comment_arrow
Patch_comments_icon

Zak Koeske

10:05 am on Friday, March 1, 2013

@Lenny - Both that story and the one on NJ.com are wrong. Cook was never suspended. He was on paid administrative leave for a few weeks during the internal affairs investigation and returned full-time to his position when the investigation concluded.

LENNY

12:49 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

ZAK thank you for the correct information.

Reply

Stuart Pace

12:49 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

Imagine that. the Record got something wrong.................

Reply

Hans Ulhman

5:25 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

The story should not be about who's leaving, it should be about the damage that has been left behind. FLPD has not been right since Maryann Collura's murder.

Reply

debvaun

5:25 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

I for one am sorry to see Capt. Cook go. I wish him the best in His next venture. Now that He is gone lets see who will be next on the chopping block....

Reply

JV233

5:25 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

I'm going to go out on a limb, since the murder of Officer Collura there has been visible issues within the FLPD, and I only hope that the elected officials see this and get the department the help it needs.

Reply

Mike. Litoris

5:25 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

The Captain always thought he was a ladies man and always thought he was untouchable above everyone else. It's Karma. Now lets hope the Borough is smart enough to put people with Leadership skills in a Leadership position. Not dictators or puppets.......

Reply
Comment_arrow

Stuart Pace

1:49 am on Saturday, March 2, 2013

and that will be ....................?

Puzzled

5:25 pm on Friday, March 1, 2013

Yes stuart that's what we should place importance upon here

Reply
Comment_arrow

Stuart Pace

1:49 am on Saturday, March 2, 2013

be careful what you wish for puzzled. When the County chief comes to FL as director, watch what happens.

BleedsBlue

1:49 am on Saturday, March 2, 2013

Hans & JV, with all due respect it is totally repulsive to hear the dysfunction blamed on the death of a Officer Collura.
The no confidence vote says it all

Reply

BleedsBlue

3:34 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

Pretty interesting statement Mr. Pace, considering all your past comments are supporting the very administration in which the no confidence vote was aimed at

Reply

Concerned

3:34 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

The department could use a director. There is much dysfunction!!!
The town needs to put the right people in charge.
A no confidence vote does say it all!!!

Reply

Walter Weglein

3:34 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

This is a very sensitive story...I respect anyone on here who doesn't cravenly hide behind a pseudonym...bravo esp. to Stuart!

Reply

tacitus

3:34 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

Whether people want to admit to this or not, the pd has not been the same since Officer Collura's death; it has neither recovered nor fully healed since that terrible loss. Many, many of today's issues stem from that tragic incident; the Borough failed to put in place strong leadership in the aftermath and the pd has suffered ever since.

Reply

Stuart Pace

4:09 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

I fully support Chief and Capt. I believe It is the motives of past and present Boro leadership that is behind the destruction of the PD.

Reply
Comment_arrow

reasoning

11:10 am on Monday, March 4, 2013

im really curious with your reasoning w/ this situation. when officers are pressing charges on the chief and captain and after a vote the MAJORITY of our officers express no confidence in the leadership of the captain and chief, what does that have to do with the borough leadership? are you saying kneer's lawsuit is unjustified, or our officers were angry w/ the borough and decided to take it out on the captain and chief?
if the CEO of my complany lays off people in my department i am not going to take it out on the head of my department and press charges on him.
kneer is pressing charges on rose and cook for harrassment, how in the world is that the fault of the borough leadership, did they order rose and cook to mistreat kneer? are you assuming kneer is a liar as well as all the officers who expressed no confidence in their leadership?
sounds like someone is bitter about not being selected for town council and blaming all the town issues on the people who were selected.

Go Figure

4:09 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

This is a very sensitive subject and now appears to be mostly the past. Hopefully the department can soon move forward in a very positive direction. I have met many of the officers and know that we have a great department. Seems to me that with the civil service system we might not always get the right leader for the job, but this is our form of government service. Of course a director could circumvent that system. Hopefully our town leaders will make the right decision for the future of a very important part of our community -- public safety!

Reply

BleedsBlue

5:29 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

Mr Pace, are you telling us the behavior which brought a no confidence vote upon them was a result of " puppeteers " ie:" Boro leadership" as you have labeled it?

Reply

Go Figure

11:05 pm on Saturday, March 2, 2013

It's laudable to defend one's friends, but my guess is that there is something up when 92% of an organization attests that it is so. Just a thought.

Reply

Concerned

11:19 pm on Sunday, March 3, 2013

Derek is not the answer, nothing against him tho...
The department needs an outsider to come in and set everyone straight. The cops need to be cops again and be able to perform their duties with efficient leadership.

Reply

Freddie Harrison

9:56 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Of course they will never be the same from Maryann's death because everyone was at the gas shack, you can't move forward when you are riddled with guilt. As far as I can observe they are still at that gas shack not doing their jobs. The no confidence vote doesn't really mean anything when it comes from a bunch of crying babies who think they deserve more when all they really do is talk to each other in parking lots and hide out. Hopefully the department can be steered into a more productive environment, but that would mean we would not only have to lose the chief, according to your posts, but 2/3 of the department also. Do you know anyone willing to do that?

Reply

Just Facts

9:56 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Thre are 50 something police officers in F.L.P.D. - surely there are a few that can lead them in right direction. Why hire and spend big bucks on an outsider who has no idea about Fair Lawn. My neighbors always talk nice about the police in here in town. They seem to be doing the job outside

Reply

BeInformed

11:12 pm on Monday, March 4, 2013

Sounds like Freddie always wanted to be a Policeman but couldn't get a passing score.

Reply

Concernedone

12:00 pm on Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Great minds discuss ideas; Average minds discuss events; Small minds discuss people. ...Eleanor Roosevelt

Those who care about the town, think about where you fit here.....

Reply

Michael OBrien

10:38 am on Friday, March 8, 2013

As we move through this period of transition, be assured that the members of Fair Lawn PBA Local 67 have always and will continue to protect and serve the community with honor and distinction.

Reply

ReadAllAboutIt

1:07 am on Sunday, March 10, 2013

Period of transition?!
That's like Noah calling the flood a sunshower!

Reply

disgusted

9:18 am on Tuesday, April 23, 2013

Sounds like somone needs to be brought in from the outside

Reply

Leave a comment