Disclaimer: The embedded video contains adult language
I was in Germany a while ago, visiting relatives and friends. As always when we’re there, we spent some time sightseeing. I had always wanted to see Dresden, with its beautiful and historic churches and ancient sites. So one warm summer day we toured Dresden.
It was hot, we did a lot of walking. I woke up the next morning in our hotel room, and everything was spinning. I could barely stand up. I’ve had vertigo in the past, but it has always quickly disappeared. This time, hours passed and it didn’t go away. So later that day, back at our cousin's' house, we decided to see a doctor.
Now, our relatives live in a small town, Eisenach, in the former German Democratic Republic/East Germany. It's rural and scenic. Eisenach doesn't have a big, modern hospital. It does have a small, modern clinic, open twenty-four hours a day, seven days a week.
So we drove to the hospital one bright weekday afternoon. We stopped at the receptionist's desk, explained why we were there, and that I had a pacemaker. We showed them my passport. They asked us to take a seat. The waiting area was clean, well-lit and comfortable.
We waited five minutes, before they called us into an examining room. Herr Dr. Schwartz was a youngish man who oversaw my being hooked up to an electrocardiogram machine.
Someone placed a thermometer under my tongue. Someone else placed a clip on my thumb to check my blood oxygen. And all the while, Dr. Schwartz asked me what had happened the day before my vertigo started.
Finally, he looked at me, explained that my blood pressure was very high, the electrocardiogram showed that my heart was fine, and that my problem was a consequence of exposure to heat, as well as exhaustion and dehydration. They administered an oral mist medication which quickly brought down my blood pressure. They calmly explained all this to me, and discharged me. The whole thing took about an hour.
Before we left, someone asked if they should bill us; should they send the bill to our home in the USA? No, we said, we'd prefer to settle the bill now, if it wasn't too high. It wasn't. The bill came to a total of thirty-five dollars.
The system for health care in Germany is referred to by some in the US as “socialized
medicine.” No one in Europe thinks twice about it. No voices are raised to call for the elimination of this oppressive yoke around the necks of the people. People that we talked to all seemed to be happy with it. If this is socialized medicine, why don't we have it?
Why is it...how did it happen...that so many people here have been convinced that it's a great idea, a worthy goal, to vote against, you heard me, against, their own interest? From fighting health care, to climate change denial, to being urged not to have children vaccinated, to opposing fluoridation of water, to expecting everyone to bow to religious beliefs that many of us do not have about things like family planning and teaching evolution in science courses in our schools, to granting people the right to carry firearms into churches, college campuses and bars, so we can “stand our ground.” Will the madness ever end? Will it finally ever end?
BellairBerdan
8:10 pm on Tuesday, March 27, 2012
Great post. i wish others traveled and could see how the rest of the world works.
Allan E. Fineberg
9:21 pm on Tuesday, March 27, 2012
For such a vast country, stretching from sea to shining sea, we seem to be rather insular, do we not?
Chris Antonelli
10:55 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Allan,
Sounds like you had a nice visit to Germany and made it back safe and healthy. My only issue with your blog is that you didn't include the issues and troubles going on in the Euro zone due to socialized medicine and Socialism in general. You happened to visit one of the Eurozone powerhouses. Do you feel you would have received the same treatment in Greece, Italy, Portugal or Ireland? You very well may have, but the facts speak for themselves. Socialism as a whole is driving countries to bankruptcy. The PIIGS of the Eurozone have unsustainable debt and are on the verge of collapse. Greece has been bailed out numerous times and austerity measures have failed to quell the economic problems. In fact, it is quite possible we will see countries withdraw from the Eurozone within the next 5 years. This will have a rippling effect on the global economy.
Tommy P
11:18 pm on Tuesday, March 27, 2012
We already have lots of socialized medicine, Medicare, Medicaid and VA. In the news today SCOTUS is hearing the so called Obamacare case. If you think socialized medicine is soo good, visit a VA hospital. Ask yourself why so many Candians including political leaders come here. The Italian Prime Minster was here a few years back, members of the Saudi royal family, and many other foreign leaders all come here. Couple this with the employer provided health insurance system which is a progressive throw back from FDR's price controls, yet we have a system the best care in the world. Want better care? end the existing socialize medicine we already have.
Liberty is NOT against one's interest.
Chris Antonelli
10:40 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
A lot of Vets don't go to VA hospitals due to the substandard care and the fact that if they screw up, you have no recourse.
Allan E. Fineberg
6:32 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
"The Italian Prime Minster was here a few years back, members of the Saudi royal family, and many other foreign leaders all come here." Need I say any more?
Tommy P
11:22 am on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Cool another former socialist who has seen the light?!? They came to private facilities for private care. They had the option to use their "free" socialized medicine at home. Yet choose to come here.
BellairBerdan
12:37 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
TP The Patch Patriot's words come right out of the Tea Party playbook. I know quite a few Canadians. They all love their system and the ones that live around here all go back to Canada for their treatment, as have many Americans for their medications because it is cheaper.
Is a system geared to only service the rich of the world while ignoring the people in our own country really something to brag about? We may have the best health care in the world but it is only available to the rich. The People will never see it. We are the only advanced country in the world without healthcare for all. We pay more and get less.
BTW, Medicare was formed because insurance companies wouldn't insure the old. They didn't turn a profit. Medicaid is only for pregnant women and children in poverty, making less than 12K per year. No men allowed. If you think you have no responsibility to fund the care of veterans, the people who gave of themselves so you can have your selfish freedoms, you have a very sorry spirit.
Tommy P
9:46 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
There are many voices in the nation, not just the Occupiers and TEA Partiers.
Pointing out that our system is largely influenced by government programs doesn't mean I am against government covering any health care costs. Rest assured I am against socialized medicine because costs go up, quality goes down and bureaucrat make decisions on care instead of doctors and patients.
You know some Canadians, I have family there, that doesn't make either one of us experts. The "Canadian Wings" of hospitals on our norther border speak volumes. The waiting lists for many basic services are not something most Americans support.
When we look at health procedures where insurance is not involved, ie cosmetic surgery, lasik, etc the prices go down. Have a child in Hackensack, I understand they are over $60 for a c-section. Third party payer systems also have the same basic flaw. If you spend your money on yourself, you think about quality and cost. When you spend your money on someone else, you think about cost, and see so about quality. When you spend someone else's money on someone else, you don't care about quality nor cost. Its human nature.
Your characterization of only the rich getting care is a departure from reality. Most people in this town can easily afford health care despite the government's interference driving up the price.
Chris Antonelli
10:38 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
Obamacare, in the long term, is unsustainable financially.
BellairBerdan
11:01 am on Thursday, March 29, 2012
If you think Americans don't wait for services you're wrong. Many people have to wait months to get a doctors appointment. You may not want a bureaucrat making your health decisions, but why do you want an insurance company executive whose profit depends on denying your claim to make those decisions?
Your hypothesis about cost is wrong as well. That is proven in every other industrialized country.
But when you say "most" people in our affluent town can afford it, that says it all. Every person should be able to afford it.
Tommy P
9:10 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
There is always an emergency room, an yes, if its not life threatening, there usually is a wait. However, there is a difference between a few hours and many months. Dentists have lead times as well, particularly if you want service at a time that is convenient to most people.
If I am unhappy with my insurance carrier, I can get another. If I don't like my government insurance, I am screwed. Agreements made with insurance companies are contracts subject to law. It it weren't for the progressives/liberals in the 1940s instituting wage control and subsequently use the tax code to continue employer provided health care, we would have a free market. Car insurance works, cosmetic surgery gets cheaper year over year. Yet it costs $100s of thousands if you have a heart attack, tens of thousands to have a baby, etc. All because of the skewed payer system we have.
My statements were not hypotheses but rather common sense observations. You'd didn't challenge them for a reason. Instead you claimed the implication was wrong. If the rest of the world was good at health care, why do the vast majority of new drugs come from America?
Health insurance and health care are two different things. They should be treated as such.
Allan E. Fineberg
1:04 pm on Wednesday, March 28, 2012
Rush Limbaugh had a heart problem while on vacation in Hawaii. Shortly thereafter, he held a press conference in which he extolled the hospital and its staff for his excellent treatment. PS: he happens to be a millionaire.
Allan E. Fineberg
9:26 pm on Thursday, March 29, 2012
This is what The Borowitz Report has to say:
http://www.borowitzreport.com/2012/03/29/an-argument-against-healthcare/
Michael Agosta
5:40 am on Saturday, March 31, 2012
Mr Fineberg,
Nice post.
Unfortunately, you forgot to mention that your excursion to the clinic that day was subsidized by the German population that pays a 65% tax rate. That was the tax rate when I visited Germany in 2007.
I was stationed in Germany for 7 years from 84-91. The tax rate was 50%. Many Germans had private insurance policies becasue the socialized health care was/is not adequate.
Your wonderful experience was limited to an elevation in blood pressure and simple dehydration. If you had a heart attack or cancer, that's where the challenges begin. Socialized health care is rationed. Period.
For those of you who really don't leave Bergen County, you should do a bit more research before showing such excitement for this type of health care.
BellairBerdan
11:25 am on Sunday, April 1, 2012
The income tax rate in Germany is a sliding scale from 0-45%. In addition to providing health care there is also little to no additional cost to attend many of Germany's universities.
When a private insurance company denies a claim or limits coverage, you are also being rationed.
If you are saying you were "stationed" and were in the armed service your health care was being paid for by everyone's taxes, socialized you may say.
Tommy P
9:17 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
Yet more ignorance, or willful omission? I have an employee in Frankfurt. He points out that in addition to the income tax, there is VAT of 19% of most goods, and a solidarity surcharge of 5.5%. My guess is you googled german taxation and read the first paragraph.
When a contract doesn't cover a procedure, that's not a ration. It's simple a risk not covered. When the government takes over a business and reduces service, the word ration applies.
BellairBerdan, I am curious, which government school(s) did you attend?
Michael Agosta
10:27 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
I guess I should discard my first-hand knowledge for something you read on Wiki.
"In addition to providing health care there is also little to no additional cost to attend many of Germany's universities." Who pays for all these "free" perks?
I was "stationed" there....I was in the Army. The taxpayers paid for my health care. That's what we do for our armed services. It is something that is EARNED. I have Tricare insurance, which I EARNED after serving 20 years in the US Army. It is socialized/rationed medicine. That is why I am against Obamacare. I live it.
If you decide to wander outside of Bergen County one day, you may borrow my GPS.
BellairBerdan
4:07 pm on Monday, April 2, 2012
Well, TP the Patch Patriot, it seems you are the one full of willful omission. That 45% tax is for couples making over $668K per year. The majority of people pay about 29%. That solidarity surcharge is also on a linear scale according to salary, topping at 5.5%. ( I'm sure you just forgot to put those parts in) If you'd like to add those other costs onto their tax burden it would only be fair to add those similar burdens, sales, property, water taxes and cost of health ins and college debt to the American's rate. If you actually did that and compared apples to apples you'd see we would be paying more than those in Germany and getting less.
To Michael I will discard your firsthand knowledge because it is simply untrue. Those "perks" aren't free. They are paid for by taxes and are EARNED by the people just as you feel you earn your perks. BTW that's a pretty good deal you have. Spend only 20 yrs at a job, learning your trade while paid by the people, Then retire early, get a pension and lifetime health insurance. Then you take the knowledge the people paid for get another job and yet another salary while taking that job away from a soldier.You got a pretty good deal. It's a shame to see you always wanting to deny similar for others. It's also sad to see you knock your own benefits. You can always give them up. But, I bet you still take advantage of them, don't you?
Mei Won Sum
4:22 pm on Monday, April 2, 2012
(In regards to Mike) As Bellair types that from the comfort of his/her home while rockets and bombs are NOT exploding around the neighborhood.
Michael Agosta
9:57 pm on Monday, April 2, 2012
Bellair, you are funny.
Spend only 20 years? Have you ever been in the military? I pay more than teachers do for medical....it's not free. My retirement is less than social security. It is no where near what a teacher earns after they retire. I don't complain about the benefits I EARNED.
So, now I am taking a job away from a soldier? Your ignorance is profound. Since Viet Nam, the military has employed civilian advisors. The roles of civilian contractors has grown since the early 90s....after Desert Storm. The military depends upon the services provided by us, the contractors. Having never left your living room, you wouldn't understand.
I will be in Germany for a week in June. I'll be sure to enlighten my friends there about the taxes they pay. They will be thankful to you for explaining so clearly.
Allan E. Fineberg
2:07 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
I guess we could go round and round on this topic endlessly. The bottom line is that there are two types of minds. This is a talk by the psychologist Jonathan Haidt on the differences between liberals and conservatives.
http://www.ted.com/talks/jonathan_haidt_on_the_moral_mind.html
Tommy P
9:31 pm on Sunday, April 1, 2012
The world is not that simple, you have totalitarians (communists/dictators/etc), socialists (including progressives and other statists), big government conservatives, tea party conservatives, libertarians, etc.
Haidt is both simplistic and too lenient toward moral beliefs that have historically led to mass murder and totalitarianism. Using his logic, Chairman Mao, Stalin, etc are simply liberals.